[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Results for General Resolution: Lenny and resolving DFSG violations



Greetings,

	This message is an automated, unofficial publication of vote results.
 Official results shall follow, sent in by the vote taker, namely
Debian Project Secretary

	This email is just a convenience for the impatient.
 I remain, gentle folks,

    Your humble servant,
    Devotee (on behalf of Debian Project Secretary)

    -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-

Starting results calculation at Sun Dec 28 00:03:02 2008

Option 1 "Reaffirm the Social Contract"
Option 2 "Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]"
Option 3 "Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]"
Option 4 "Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations [3:1]"
Option 5 "Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise"
Option 6 "Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]"
Option 7 "Further Discussion"

In the following table, tally[row x][col y] represents the votes that
option x received over option y.

                  Option
              1     2     3     4     5     6     7 
            ===   ===   ===   ===   ===   ===   === 
Option 1           46    60    72    73    89   117 
Option 2    281         160   160   171   177   224 
Option 3    255    61         125   137   151   204 
Option 4    253   121   146         160   166   194 
Option 5    234   105   128   135         136   191 
Option 6    220   118   134   125   134         180 
Option 7    226   129   145   153   160   169       



Looking at row 2, column 1, Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]
received 281 votes over Reaffirm the Social Contract

Looking at row 1, column 2, Reaffirm the Social Contract
received 46 votes over Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1].

Option 1 Reached quorum: 117 > 47.8591684006314
Option 2 Reached quorum: 224 > 47.8591684006314
Option 3 Reached quorum: 204 > 47.8591684006314
Option 4 Reached quorum: 194 > 47.8591684006314
Option 5 Reached quorum: 191 > 47.8591684006314
Option 6 Reached quorum: 180 > 47.8591684006314


Dropping Option 1 because of Majority. (0.5176991150442477876106194690265486725664)  0.518 (117/226) < 1
Dropping Option 2 because of Majority. (1.736434108527131782945736434108527131783)  1.736 (224/129) < 3
Dropping Option 3 because of Majority. (1.406896551724137931034482758620689655172)  1.407 (204/145) < 3
Dropping Option 4 because of Majority. (1.267973856209150326797385620915032679739)  1.268 (194/153) < 3
Option 5 passes Majority.               1.194 (191/160) >= 1
Dropping Option 6 because of Majority. (1.065088757396449704142011834319526627219)  1.065 (180/169) < 3


  Option 5 defeats Option 7 by ( 191 -  160) =   31 votes.


The Schwartz Set contains:
	 Option 5 "Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise"



-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

The winners are:
	 Option 5 "Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise"

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

-- 
The voters have spoken, the bastards... --unknown
DEbian VOTe EnginE
digraph Results {
  ranksep=0.25;
 "Reaffirm the Social Contract\n0.52" [ style="filled" , color="pink", shape=octagon, fontname="Helvetica", fontsize=10  ];
 "Further Discussion" -> "Reaffirm the Social Contract\n0.52" [ label="109" ];
 "Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]\nMajority=1.74" -> "Reaffirm the Social Contract\n0.52" [ label="235",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations [3:1]\nMajority=1.27" -> "Reaffirm the Social Contract\n0.52" [ label="181",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]\nMajority=1.41" -> "Reaffirm the Social Contract\n0.52" [ label="195",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]\nMajority=1.07" -> "Reaffirm the Social Contract\n0.52" [ label="131",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]\n1.74" [ style="filled" , color="pink", shape=octagon, fontname="Helvetica", fontsize=10  ];
 "Further Discussion" -> "Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]\n1.74" [ label="-95" ];
 "Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]\n1.41" [ style="filled" , color="pink", shape=octagon, fontname="Helvetica", fontsize=10  ];
 "Further Discussion" -> "Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]\n1.41" [ label="-59" ];
 "Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]\nMajority=1.74" -> "Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]\n1.41" [ label="99",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations [3:1]\nMajority=1.27" -> "Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]\n1.41" [ label="21",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations [3:1]\n1.27" [ style="filled" , color="pink", shape=octagon, fontname="Helvetica", fontsize=10  ];
 "Further Discussion" -> "Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations [3:1]\n1.27" [ label="-41" ];
 "Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]\nMajority=1.74" -> "Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations [3:1]\n1.27" [ label="39",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise\n1.19" [ style="filled" , color="powderblue", shape=egg, fontcolor="NavyBlue", fontname="Helvetica", fontsize=10  ];
 "Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise\n1.19" -> "Further Discussion" [ label="31" ];
 "Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]\n1.07" [ style="filled" , color="pink", shape=octagon, fontname="Helvetica", fontsize=10  ];
 "Further Discussion" -> "Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]\n1.07" [ label="-11" ];
 "Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]\nMajority=1.74" -> "Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]\n1.07" [ label="59",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations [3:1]\nMajority=1.27" -> "Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]\n1.07" [ label="41",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]\nMajority=1.41" -> "Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]\n1.07" [ label="17",  style="dotted", color="pink" ];
 "Further Discussion" [ style="filled" , shape=diamond, fontcolor="Red", fontname="Helvetica", fontsize=10  ];
}

Attachment: pgpFPTZrNEh0V.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Reply to: