Le lun 28 août 2006 20:35, Anthony Towns a écrit : > Hello, world! > > […] > > Note that both these polls are just an informal way of finding out > what people think, and while they will be considered and taken into > account, they won't necessarily be the final word on the matter. I'm very suprised by that mail that completely forgot to mention the ongoing discussions about a GR about firmwares. There is already three proposals for that GR[1] and I wonder why those have not been mentionned. I'm also worried that the debate seems to be presented as "relase etch in time and put firmwares in main" versus "care about firmware freeness and release later". That's not what has been discussed on debian-vote for one or two weeks already. The current amendments all have the corrolary that etch won't be delayed, either because an exception will be proposed (don's proposal) or because we don't care about firmware until we have a viable technical solution to do the split (joss's proposal) or because we decide that firmwares are not programatical things (steve's proposal). Given that, and that you are not able to assure the users that the result of their poll will be followed: * I fear that the issues of those polls would put pressure on the GR voters, * I also fear that if the GR issue is not what the polls showed that the user wanted, we will have a hard time to cope with our angry users, that will feel they have been made as a fool of that story. So question to the DPL: I really wonder why a formal announce of that unofficial poll has been made, instead of encouraging people to review the amendments that have been proposed, and even propose a new one if needed, so that that GR can come, and that we know where we are going instead of guessing. [1] http://lists.debian.org/debian-vote/2006/08/msg00032.html http://lists.debian.org/debian-vote/2006/08/msg00215.html http://lists.debian.org/debian-vote/2006/08/msg00185.html -- ·O· Pierre Habouzit ··O madcoder@debian.org OOO http://www.madism.org
Attachment:
pgpKVG4jI2cWz.pgp
Description: PGP signature