Re: Bug#340428: octave2.9 - lists mailing list as uploader in changelog
[Please, Cc: to me, I am not currently subscribed to debian-devel.]
* Thiemo Seufer <firstname.lastname@example.org> [2005-11-24 02:13]:
> Stephen Gran wrote:
> > FWIW, Rafael, at first blush I have to say I agree with you. A
> > maintainer address in Debian is just a way to get in touch with someone
> > when something goes wrong with the package. If the mailing list is a
> > good way to get in touch with people when those packages break, then it
> > seems like a reasonable maintainer address.
> AFAIU the changelog entry is supposed to bear the name of the uploader,
> and thus can't be a mailing list. Policy 4.4 seems to support this:
> "The maintainer name and email address used in the changelog should
> be the details of the person uploading this version. They are not
> necessarily those of the usual package maintainer."
> > Bastian, what's the rationale for the filings you've been doing? Do you
> > really think a mailing list address, (where any and all correspondence
> > about the packages is presumably archived and possibly even publicly
> > accessible), is somehow worse than mailing a single person (who
> > hopefully archives their package mail, but maybe not, and can almost be
> > guaranteed not to have publicly browseable archives)? What are you
> > hoping to do here?
> It provides a convenient way to find the person who did the final
> touches before an upload. The uses you are arguing are covered by
> the Maintainer: field.
I think that are two distinct concepts here. The first is the maintainer
of the package, which should receive any e-mail messages related to the
package. This name appears in the debian/changelog entry as well as in
the Maintainer field. All correspondence must be directed to this entity
(either a person or a mailing list).
The second concept is the real, physical person who did a specific
upload. This appears in the Changed-By field and is used to know who is
responsible for that upload. If this person is in the Uploaders field of
debian/control, then debian-installer will not consider the upload as an
NMU. Furthermore, this information is in the changes file and also
stored in the debian-devel-changes mailing list archive.