[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Incorrect use of "it's" in package control files -- file mass bug?



* Kevin B. McCarty:

> Recall that "it's" is a contraction for "it is" or "it has", and any other 
> use (e.g. as a possessive) is not grammatically correct English. 
> Hypothetical examples:
>
> - XMMS is cool.  It's one of the best ...   [correct, "It is"]
> - XMMS is cool.  It's been rated highly ... [correct, "It has"]
> - XMMS is cool.  It's features include ...  [wrong]
> - XMMS is cool.  Its features include ...   [correct, possessive]
>
> Using "it's" and "its" correctly is in your best interest, since incorrect 
> usage may cause someone browsing the package descriptions to have a bad 
> first impression of that package.

If this is really important, lintian could enforce a style guide that
prohibts "it's" altogether, always requiring the spelled-out versions.
(While we are at it, "e.g." and "i.e." are good candidates for a ban,
too. 8-)



Reply to: