[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Every spam is sacred

Anthony DeRobertis <asd@suespammers.org> a tapoté :

> On Thursday, Jun 12, 2003, at 08:04 US/Eastern, Mathieu Roy wrote:
> > "they do so out of a practical desire to get their mail delivered",
> > it's
> > a game of word. By fear of having some of their mail not delivered,
> > they avoid some ISP.
> And, so?
> >
> > You deliberately harm innocent people using these ISP just because
> > they use this ISP.
> Yeah, in the same sense I deliberately harm a telemarketer by refusing
> to buy his wares, getting an answering machine, or just hanging up on
> him.

If you cut the phone-line the telemarketer is using because you think
he is doing a nasty job, yes.

> You seem to be missing a fundamental distinction between murder and
> refusal to communicate:
> 	1) You have a right to live
> 	2) You have no right to communicate with me against my wishes.
> 	   Further, I have a right to refuse to communicate with you.

Your 2 is off-topic. 

We're a speaking of a general policy, a system-wide policy, not an
individual policy.

The 2 would be in fact
        2) You have no right to broke communication between two
        persons just because you do not like the ISP of the sender

Mathieu Roy
  Not a native english speaker: 

Reply to: