[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#350739: marked as done (cdrtools: GPL violation - makefiles distributed under non-GPL-compatible license)

Your message dated Sun, 03 Sep 2006 15:07:42 -0700
with message-id <E1GK07y-0004hL-67@spohr.debian.org>
and subject line Bug#350739: fixed in cdrkit 5:1.0~pre1-1
has caused the attached Bug report to be marked as done.

This means that you claim that the problem has been dealt with.
If this is not the case it is now your responsibility to reopen the
Bug report if necessary, and/or fix the problem forthwith.

(NB: If you are a system administrator and have no idea what I am
talking about this indicates a serious mail system misconfiguration
somewhere.  Please contact me immediately.)

Debian bug tracking system administrator
(administrator, Debian Bugs database)
--- Begin Message --- 
Package: cdrtools
Severity: serious
Justification: Policy 2.3

In cdrtools 2.01.01a03 license of several makefiles have been changed to a
custom version of CDDL, which is a non-GPL-compatible license. These
makefiles are used to build GPL-licensed binaries, which is a violation of
paragraph 3 of the GPL:

  3. You may copy and distribute the Program (or a work based on it, under
     Section 2) in object code or executable form under the terms of
     Sections 1 and 2 above provided that you also do one of the following:

      a) Accompany it with the complete corresponding machine-readable
         source code, WHICH MUST BE DISTRIBUTED UNDER THE TERMS OF SECTIONS
         1 AND 2 ABOVE on a medium customarily used for software
         interchange;

... and:

     For an executable work, complete source code means all the source code
     for all modules it contains, plus any associated interface definition
     files, PLUS THE SCRIPTS USED TO CONTROL COMPILATION AND INSTALLATION OF
     THE EXECUTABLE.

... (emphasis mine). As a result, the package is non-distributable.

The mentioned files are:

RULES/9000-725-hp-ux-cc.rul
RULES/9000-725-hp-ux-gcc.rul
RULES/MKLINKS
RULES/alpha-osf1-cc.rul
RULES/alpha-osf1-gcc.rul
RULES/aviion-dgux3-cc.rul
RULES/aviion-dgux3-gcc.rul
RULES/aviion-dgux4-cc.rul
RULES/aviion-dgux4-gcc.rul
RULES/bemac-beos-cc.rul
RULES/bemac-beos-mwcc.rul
RULES/bepc-beos-cc.rul
RULES/bepc-beos-gcc.rul
RULES/dn5500-domainos-cc.rul
RULES/dummy.dep
RULES/hppa-nextstep-cc.rul
RULES/hppa-nextstep-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-at386-gnu-cc.rul
RULES/i386-at386-gnu-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-bsd-os-cc.rul
RULES/i386-bsd-os-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-bsd-os3-cc.rul
RULES/i386-bsd-os3-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-freebsd-cc.rul
RULES/i386-freebsd-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-mingw32_nt-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-ms-dos-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-netbsd-cc.rul
RULES/i386-netbsd-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-openbsd-cc.rul
RULES/i386-openbsd-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-openserver-cc.rul
RULES/i386-openserver-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-os2-gcc.rul
RULES/i386-unixware-cc.rul
RULES/i386-unixware-gcc.rul
RULES/i486-cygwin32_nt-cc.rul
RULES/i486-cygwin32_nt-gcc.rul
RULES/i486-mingw32_nt-gcc.rul
RULES/i586-linux-cc.rul
RULES/i586-linux-gcc.rul
RULES/i586-mingw32_nt-gcc.rul
RULES/i686-mingw32_nt-gcc.rul
RULES/i786-mingw32_nt-gcc.rul
RULES/i86pc-sunos5-cc.rul
RULES/i86pc-sunos5-gcc.rul
RULES/ip22-irix-cc.rul
RULES/ip22-irix-gcc.rul
RULES/ldummy.cnf
RULES/local.cnf
RULES/m68k-amigaos-gcc.rul
RULES/man-bsd.def
RULES/man-sysv.def
RULES/mk-.id
RULES/mk-gmake.id
RULES/mk-smake.id
RULES/news4000-newsos6-cc.rul
RULES/os-aix.def
RULES/os-aix.id
RULES/os-amigaos.def
RULES/os-amigaos.id
RULES/os-beos.def
RULES/os-beos.id
RULES/os-bsd-os.def
RULES/os-bsd-os.id
RULES/os-bsd-os3.def
RULES/os-cygwin32_nt.def
RULES/os-cygwin32_nt.id
RULES/os-darwin.def
RULES/os-darwin.id
RULES/os-dgux.id
RULES/os-dgux3.def
RULES/os-dgux4.def
RULES/os-domainos.def
RULES/os-domainos.id
RULES/os-freebsd.def
RULES/os-freebsd.id
RULES/os-gnu.def
RULES/os-gnu.id
RULES/os-hp-ux.def
RULES/os-hp-ux.id
RULES/os-irix.def
RULES/os-irix.id
RULES/os-linux.def
RULES/os-linux.id
RULES/os-mac-os.id
RULES/os-mac-os10.def
RULES/os-mingw32_95-4.0.id
RULES/os-mingw32_98-4.0.id
RULES/os-mingw32_98-4.10.id
RULES/os-mingw32_me-4.90.id
RULES/os-mingw32_nt-4.0.id
RULES/os-mingw32_nt-5.0.id
RULES/os-mingw32_nt-5.1.id
RULES/os-mingw32_nt-5.2.id
RULES/os-mingw32_nt.def
RULES/os-mingw32_nt.id
RULES/os-ms-dos.def
RULES/os-ms-dos.id
RULES/os-netbsd.def
RULES/os-netbsd.id
RULES/os-news-os.id
RULES/os-newsos6.def
RULES/os-nextstep.def
RULES/os-nextstep.id
RULES/os-openbsd.def
RULES/os-openbsd.id
RULES/os-openserver.def
RULES/os-os-2.id
RULES/os-os2.def
RULES/os-osf1.def
RULES/os-osf1.id
RULES/os-qnx.def
RULES/os-qnx.id
RULES/os-rhapsody.def
RULES/os-rhapsody.id
RULES/os-sco_sv.id
RULES/os-sunos.id
RULES/os-sunos4.def
RULES/os-sunos5.def
RULES/os-unix_sv.id
RULES/os-unixware.def
RULES/os-unixware.id
RULES/pci-qnx-cc.rul
RULES/power-macintosh-darwin-cc.rul
RULES/power-macintosh-darwin-gcc.rul
RULES/power-macintosh-rhapsody-cc.rul
RULES/power-macintosh-rhapsody-gcc.rul
RULES/powerpc-beos-gcc.rul
RULES/powerpc-beos-mwcc.rul
RULES/r-gmake.dep
RULES/r-gmake.tag
RULES/r-make.dep
RULES/r-make.obj
RULES/r-make.tag
RULES/r-smake.dep
RULES/r-smake.obj
RULES/r-smake.tag
RULES/rs6000-aix-cc.rul
RULES/rs6000-aix-gcc.rul
RULES/rules.aux
RULES/rules.clr
RULES/rules.cmd
RULES/rules.cnf
RULES/rules.dep
RULES/rules.dir
RULES/rules.drv
RULES/rules.hlp
RULES/rules.inc
RULES/rules.ins
RULES/rules.lib
RULES/rules.lnt
RULES/rules.loc
RULES/rules.man
RULES/rules.mkd
RULES/rules.mks
RULES/rules.mod
RULES/rules.obj
RULES/rules.prg
RULES/rules.rdi
RULES/rules.rel
RULES/rules.scr
RULES/rules.shl
RULES/rules.sps
RULES/rules.tag
RULES/rules.top
RULES/rules1.dir
RULES/rules1.top
RULES/sun3-sunos4-cc.rul
RULES/sun3-sunos4-gcc.rul
RULES/sun4-sunos4-cc.rul
RULES/sun4-sunos4-gcc.rul
RULES/sun4-sunos5-cc.rul
RULES/sun4-sunos5-gcc.rul
RULES/x86pc-qnx-gcc.rul
TEMPLATES/temp-gcc.rul
TEMPLATES/temp-xcc.rul
conf/Makefile
conf/cc-config.sh
conf/makeinc
conf/mkdep-aix.sh
conf/mkdep-hpux.sh
conf/mkdep-sco.sh
conf/mkdir-sh
conf/mkdir.sh
conf/oarch.sh
conf/setup.sh
conf/src-get
conf/srcroot.sh
conf/wget.sh
inc/align_test.c
inc/avoffset.c
inc/getfp.c


-- System Information:
Debian Release: testing/unstable
  APT prefers testing
  APT policy: (500, 'testing')
Architecture: i386 (x86_64)
Shell:  /bin/sh linked to /bin/dash
Kernel: Linux 2.6.15
Locale: LANG=C, LC_CTYPE=pl_PL.UTF8 (charmap=UTF-8)

--- End Message ---
--- Begin Message --- 
Source: cdrkit
Source-Version: 5:1.0~pre1-1

We believe that the bug you reported is fixed in the latest version of
cdrkit, which is due to be installed in the Debian FTP archive:

cdda2wav_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb
  to pool/main/c/cdrkit/cdda2wav_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb
cdrecord_1.0~pre1-1_all.deb
  to pool/main/c/cdrkit/cdrecord_1.0~pre1-1_all.deb
cdrkit-doc_1.0~pre1-1_all.deb
  to pool/main/c/cdrkit/cdrkit-doc_1.0~pre1-1_all.deb
cdrkit_1.0~pre1-1.diff.gz
  to pool/main/c/cdrkit/cdrkit_1.0~pre1-1.diff.gz
cdrkit_1.0~pre1-1.dsc
  to pool/main/c/cdrkit/cdrkit_1.0~pre1-1.dsc
cdrkit_1.0~pre1.orig.tar.gz
  to pool/main/c/cdrkit/cdrkit_1.0~pre1.orig.tar.gz
mkisofs_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb
  to pool/main/c/cdrkit/mkisofs_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb
wodim_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb
  to pool/main/c/cdrkit/wodim_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb



A summary of the changes between this version and the previous one is
attached.

Thank you for reporting the bug, which will now be closed.  If you
have further comments please address them to 350739@bugs.debian.org,
and the maintainer will reopen the bug report if appropriate.

Debian distribution maintenance software
pp.
Joerg Jaspert <joerg@debian.org> (supplier of updated cdrkit package)

(This message was generated automatically at their request; if you
believe that there is a problem with it please contact the archive
administrators by mailing ftpmaster@debian.org)


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Format: 1.7
Date: Sun,  3 Sep 2006 22:50:24 +0200
Source: cdrkit
Binary: cdda2wav cdrkit-doc mkisofs cdrecord wodim
Architecture: source amd64 all
Version: 5:1.0~pre1-1
Distribution: unstable
Urgency: low
Maintainer: Joerg Jaspert <joerg@debian.org>
Changed-By: Joerg Jaspert <joerg@debian.org>
Description: 
 cdda2wav   - Creates WAV files from audio CDs
 cdrecord   - Dummy package for transition to wodim
 cdrkit-doc - Documentation for the cdrkit package-suite
 mkisofs    - Creates ISO-9660 CD-ROM filesystem images
 wodim      - command line CD writing tool
Closes: 188827 200665 271114 278894 283794 283794 295438 304230 309250 310689 310689 312062 312062 314139 317793 324586 325766 326138 327270 329308 330506 335253 342085 344214 344443 344443 344445 350254 350738 350739 353176 353403 355291 360295 361450 361776 372484 372486 374345 374685 377145 377421 377736 379992 381954
Changes: 
 cdrkit (5:1.0~pre1-1) unstable; urgency=low
 .
   [ Eduard Bloch ]
   * dropped the shm build (kernel 2.2 is history)
   * dropped dpatch integration, we are the upstream now
   * disabled debconf messages and device-creating code for now
     (closes: #326138, #314139); things like hints to create device files are
     essential for only few people and can equaly be presented as program
     messages. Why shall we still MAKEDEV them?  It's not like we have switched
     to kernel 2.0.1 yesterday (closes: #342085, #188827, #200665)
   * updated Build-Dependencies for kfreebsd (closes: #355291)
   * debian/copyright got uptodate mail address for Schilling (closes: #372484)
 .
   [ Eduard Bloch, upstream related changes ]
   * The Big Fork to an independent project called cdrkit
     + using the last clearly stated GPLed versions of files from
       cdrtools-2.01.01a08 (closes: #353403, #372486)
     + we play the upstream role now, using our patches and we like them
       (closes: #361450)
     + renamed relevant works to avoid claims of "potential defamation" or
       "damage of reputation" (closes: #350738)
     + custom CMake based build system used instead of the original one, since
       we understand it better (closes: #350739 and hopefully closes: #350254,
       reopen if not). It seems to be portable among the platforms
       supported by Debian, it needs a bit of work for porting to non-Linux
       plattforms, though.
   * removed most of the anti-linux2.6  program messages (unless being
     in verbose mode). (closes: #377145)
   * changed default config file location to /etc/default/wodim
   * added more meaningful error message on -dvd-video failure (closes: #324586)
   * minor cdda2mp3/cdda2ogg scripts fixes suggested by Fabian Pietsch, plus
     fixes for unreliable encoder detection (closes: #283794, #344443) plus
     possible override of preset CDDA_DEVICE variable fixed. Made the list of
     selected audiotracks modifiable, see manpage (closes: #344445)
   * sync with 4:2.01+01a01-4ubuntu4:
     + merged README.ATAPI.setup with README.ATAPI.setup.ubuntu. Kernel 2.6 part
       now in the beginning and reflecting the reality (dev=/dev/drive syntax,
       no SUID requirement, closes: #304230, #377736)
     + 02_cdrecord_default_conf.dpatch: changed /dev/cdrom to /dev/cdrw which
       is more likely to match the correct device on udev using systems
   * 36_ATA_scanbus_ignore_locked.dpatch to ignore busy devices (eg. hda
     harddisk) while scanning with dev=ATA
     (closes: #310689, #309250, #317793, #360295,
   * Included 37_clean_dvdsup.dpatch (closes: #312062) based on
     cdrtools-2.01.01a04-dvd.patch.bz2 from
     http://people.mandriva.com/~warly/files/cdrtools/ with few updates to work
     with a08. Also implements a fallback to ATA: bus in the -scanbus operation
     (closes: #310689, #278894). This patch is used instead of the old 07_....
     Enabled permanently, disabled the "cheatcode processing" in debian/rules.
     Also eliminates some useability problems that have been pushed to our
     users (closes: #325766, #271114, #312062, #353176).
   * Updated dirsplit to version 0.3.3, zisofs-tools to 1.0.7 (with a custom
     CMakeFile.txt for easier integration and config.h updated manually for
     now)
   * minor cdda2mp3/cdda2ogg scripts fixes suggested by Fabian Pietsch, plus
     fixes for unreliable encoder detection (closes: #283794, #344443) plus
     possible override of preset CDDA_DEVICE variable fixed
   * added additional script manpages from Oleksandr Moskalenko (closes: #295438)
   * changed -speed to speed= in cdrecord.1 for consistency (closes: #344214)
   * Anti-Root-Requirements:
     + 39_nonroot_skips_rezero_unit.dpatch - don't run rezero_unit() as root
     which is a) most likely not needed (even admited in the comment) and b)
     causes the whole scsi transport system to terminate
     + 40_stop_setuid_games.dpatch - another workaround for problems introduced
     in a03 - looks like Linux kernel does reject an application trying to
     change the UID between ioctls
     (closes: #335253, #374685, #330506, #329308, #374345, #377421)
   * Ubuntu's 40_fix_bad_spelling.dpatch integrated (typo in wodim.dfl)
   * increased hash size in mkisofs/hash.c (closes: #327270)
   * more decent info message about locale detection
 .
   [ Joerg Jaspert]:
   * Make build-depends on cmake versioned, to show backporters we need a recent one.
   * Bump build-depends on debhelper.
   * Kill old conflict on xcdroast, that version is no longer in Debian
   * Added a dummy cdrecord package to ease upgrades for our users. Will get removed
     some time after etch released.
   * Cleaned debian/rules a bit.
   * wodim.links: s/cdrecord/wodim/
   * Let cdrkitt-doc conflict/replace old cdrtools-doc
   * Cleaned up postinst for wodim and removed makedev dependency.
   * debhelper level 5, Policy version 3.7.2
   * Moved all buildstamps into the build/ dir
   * Dropped old install-save[d] targets.
   * No more debconf (Closes: #361776, #379992, #381954)
 .
   [ Steve McIntyre]:
   * Minor spelling/English fixes
Files: 
 2d278ffdb9c31507d67530563aa314a2 897 otherosfs optional cdrkit_1.0~pre1-1.dsc
 28d149225b02626d3bb96442c32a832d 1604483 otherosfs optional cdrkit_1.0~pre1.orig.tar.gz
 d8ff0d845ee83936d67088750d905fe0 25369 otherosfs optional cdrkit_1.0~pre1-1.diff.gz
 c4eec4b535a1f4f477323e7c7740d89d 188878 doc optional cdrkit-doc_1.0~pre1-1_all.deb
 f98690e7f7fd21107f2ffb6e912d1789 1064 otherosfs optional cdrecord_1.0~pre1-1_all.deb
 3de9dab2a9f159e4de531da89c0e87dd 398052 otherosfs optional wodim_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb
 ed9249e16e28e289eb1e4ed71adb8c25 592636 otherosfs optional mkisofs_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb
 b59e185620e66995c816711b5d284884 189426 sound optional cdda2wav_1.0~pre1-1_amd64.deb

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.5 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Joerg Jaspert <joerg@debian.org> -- Debian Developer

iD8DBQFE+02ZcV7WoH57iskRAthBAJ9kIHMtGjLqR+Q3ECp5DWF6wH6S4QCgjC7f
YHhwS3Ih52SX/B8YcAQa4gE=
=VFXc
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--- End Message ---
Reply to: