Re: LVM root?
On Wed, Oct 11, 2006 at 12:27:12PM -0400, Lennart Sorensen wrote:
> On Wed, Oct 11, 2006 at 06:04:43PM +0200, Daniel Tryba wrote:
> > with a generous 2Gb for / only and you "never" need to worry about it
> > filling up.
> > / is to valuable to lose. IMHO a single disk setup is a no go.
> > new machines get (multiple (identical) disks with) 2 partitions on them:
> > 1 - a small 2Gb (type fd)
> > 2 - the rest (type fd)
> > The small partitions are combined in a md0 array raid1, the others in
> > whatever you like (most likely 5, 1 otherwise) md1 array.
> > /dev/md0 will be used for /.
> > /dev/md1 will be a pv for lvm.
> > This adds redundancy, plus any of the partition that make up the raid1
> > for / can be mounted on its own (but writing to one will break the
> > array). Adding a disk creates an other copy of /, and with the newer
> > kernels a raid5 array can be expanded, so it can be used by the LVM.
> I like it. It matches how I setup all my machines. After having done
> Len Sorensen
I am lucky in that my backup-set size is small; Its been tight on a 100
MB Zip disk and absolutley essential stuff (stuff I need to be able to
access absolultly from anywhere, any time) fits on one floppy in gzipped
plain-text. My approach for the new root drive was to buy the most
reliable drive I could. If it dies, get a new drive and reinstall,
restore from backup and carry on.
Your approach using Raid may be overkill for me, I don't know.
The board itself has hardware SATA raid available. If I go for raid,
then I'll ask here for the advantages/disadvantages.
More to the point for me, though, is where can I get current howtos or
guides on fixing problems when things are in raid or LVM? Its a whole
new world for me and the LDP HOWTOs are too out of date, and
debian-reference doesn't cover it.
At this point I'm leaning to the single disk, regular / at 512 MB (/tmp
is separate LV) and the rest PV.
Since my / doesn't change much, when I add a second disk, just copy /
and have a non-raid copy available to boot into. When I do make
changes, just copy it over; could even make it part of the regular
Thanks for the ideas,