SPI NM

["Nils Lohner" <lohner@debian.org>]

Here are my comments from an AM perspective.  I jsut when through the
site as I would if I were intending to work on applications, and noted
what was missing, etc.  I'll do the same from an applicants perspective.

Other people's input from the applicant perspective would be useful at
this point as well.  Please go to http://nm.spi-inc.org and try
applying, and send comments to spi-general.  Please note that these
applications are trials and will be deleted before the system goes live.

- when I first log in with my AM account, I get the membership statius
  information.  There are several entry fields there which chould not
  be, as this should be an information only page.
  Expiration, AM and contrib member fields should be printed, not
  editable, and the update button should not be there. The email field
  too.  All editing should be on the 'details' page.
  Also: when I 'reload' the page, I see 'is manwoo' at the top before
  the 'NOTE!!...'  Whassat?
- when I click on an applicant from 'your applicants', I see the
  membership status for that person.  What I don't see is when the email
  check succeeded.  Again, all the input fields here should only be
  printed.  All editing should be on the 'details' page only.
  Also: add a 'back' button to the bottom of the page since a browser
  'back' action causes a "This document resulted from a POST operation
  and has expired from the cache. If you wish you can repost the form
  data to recreate the document by pressing the reload button. "
- on the 'details' page, could 'last changed' also contain the person
  who made the last change?
  Also: why can the application date be edited?  This should 
- the details page should have a 'delete application' button at the
  bottom.
- the 'applying for contrib membership' with 'You cannot apply for
  another user' shouldn't be there.
- the details page shoudl contain all the info from the status page as
  well; this page shoudl have _all_ the details fo the app.
- 'Contrib Mem Application' is checkable and uncheckable on this page.
  Why?  the non-contrib is handled automatically, so there should be no
  need to edit this field.

That's all for now.  Any chance of getting this done this week?  The
system's really close to usable now, and we have a board meeting on Aug
6 for which it would be nice to have it finished enough to decide to let
debianers in to debug it further.  At that point we can talk about
membership criteria in a little more detail as well, and get e
membership ctte together.

THanks a lot!!

Nils.