On 06/08/2015 01:54 PM, Axel Beckert wrote: > Package: wnpp > Severity: wishlist > > * Package name : gtk3-nocsd > Upstream Author : PCMan <pcman.tw -AT- gmail.com> > * URL or Web page : https://github.com/PCMan/gtk3-nocsd > * License : LGPL-2.1 > Description : LD_PRELOADable library to disable GTK+ 3 client side decoration > > gtk3-nocsd is a small LD_PRELOADable library used to disable the client > side decoration (CSD) of GTK+ 3. > > Since GTK+ 3.10, its developers added a so-called header bar or custom > title bar. With this and the client-side decoration, the original title > bar and window border provided by the window manager are disabled by > GTK+. This makes all GTK+ 3 programs look like alike. Even worse, this > may break some window manager or compositors. With the release of Jessie (and the advent of Gtk3-based software that uses CSD), I've been playing around with gtk3-nocsd myself (compiling it manually) and while I generally like the idea to return some sanity to Gtk3-based apps, there are a couple of issues that I stumbled on to (and prevent me from actually using it): - While this preloadable library does get rid of the window manager hints that disable server-side decorations, it does not get rid of the humongous title bars themselves. I've attached a screenshot featuring gedit run with preloaded gtk3-nocsd under KDE4 to illustrate the problem. While there are things there that can be considered just to be simple toolbar buttons, the windows title and the minimize/maximize/close buttons are still there and now duplicated. It looks *really* weird, and I think that's the main issue that should be solved: you also need to remove everything that can be found in the normal title bars of window managers. - Popup menus are cut off (see second attached screenshot) - if I run gedit without the preloaded lib, this doesn't happen. - It crashes some apps when preloaded; most notably virt-manager, which is in python2, but I've also seen crashes with apps that just use glib2 and not gtk3. Don't know why that is yet. - I don't think "edit your ~/.profile", as suggested by upstream, is a fantastic deployment strategy for this. It kind of goes against Debian's "just install it and it will work" mantra. Don't misunderstand me: I'm not against packaging this for Debian (in principle I'm quite in favor of it, because I absolutely loathe the current state of affairs with gtk3, and would probably be willing to package that myself), but I think there are a couple of issues that need to be ironed out first, before this becomes really usable. Regards, Christian
Attachment:
gedit_nocsd.png
Description: PNG image
Attachment:
gedit_nocsd_menus.png
Description: PNG image
