Bug#582884: [Usb-creator-hackers] Bug#582884: ITP: usb-creator -- Live USB creator
On Thu, May 27, 2010 at 12:30 PM, Ignace Mouzannar <mouzannar@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Thu, May 27, 2010 at 12:46, Alexander Reichle-Schmehl
> <tolimar@debian.org> wrote:
>> Yes, the name is too generic.
>> No, "it is already in Ubuntu" is no argument.
>> No, "it will lead to some kind of problems for Ubuntu to have it in
>> Debian with a different way) is also not an argument.
>> Yes, we have and will reject packages because of too generic names
>> (several gnustep package come to my mind).
> Here are some alternative names:
> - live-usb-creator (as Mehdi suggested earlier)
> - iso-usb-creator
> - startup-disk-creator (this is what the Gnome menu item reads [1])
> - startup-usb-creator
> - ubuntu-usb-creator
I can't say I agree, but if we're going to have to do this, we might
as well take the opportunity to make it consistent with the .desktop
file. Alexander, are you okay with startup-disk-creator?
I think if we can get rid of usb in the name, that would be good as it
can write to SD cards. I want to avoid using live in the name since,
as I previously mentioned, it can write debian-installer based images,
which are definitely not live CDs. I don't want to put Ubuntu in the
name. It writes more than just Ubuntu images (currently any
Debian-based image, but in the future any Linux distribution that uses
GRUB2).
Reply to: