[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#469397: ITP: xbmc -- XBox Media Center Linux Port



Matthew Johnson wrote:
Description: XBox Media Center Linux Port
 A media center originally written for the XBox and then ported to linux.

I intend to upload this to experimental to start with. The linux port of it is
just that. It's also designed for installation to a single directory, not
installation on a unix system. I'll need to hack round that first. The version
number is a CVS snapshot. I need to improve the long description before
uploading.
First of all, you surely must mean SVN and you should use a version number like 0.0~svn20080302, i.e. YYYYMMDD or else I'd expect an epoch pretty soon :)

I've had a look at this and even made it to successfully work on my machine. I reported some issues back to upstream (e.g. incompatibility with libmms 0.4) and told them that I was interested on bringing this to Debian. I also mentioned the FHS issue which is an obvious blocker for Debian inclusion.

I've had only negative comments; they apparently don't care about inclusion in Debian or Ubuntu (which is their platform of preference) and they just want to be able to release a liveCD that works. The FHS proposal was thought to be "too much trouble for little gain" and potentially harming the MacOSX port which is also under development.

I had a look at the code and it's a mess, because of the XDK/Windows heritage, e.g. there are conversions between Windows paths (H:\) and Linux ones (/opt/xbmc).

...and that's why I never filed an ITP and still don't regret that choice.

All in all, good luck with that ;-)
You should expect some heavy upstream patching and a potentially unfriendly upstream.

But I'd really like to see this packaged.

Thanks,
Faidon



Reply to: