[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: April 17th Draft of the Voting GR


moth@magenta.com wrote:
> However, it may be that Manoj is concerned that once the transitive
> defeat is gone the reason for dropping the defeat is gone.
... which is exactly why I am using the idea of a list. Nowhere does it say 
(in my text) that you can re-add a defeat to that list, and indeed that is 
never done, so

> If that's the case, perhaps it's worth adding a phrase such as "Once a
> defeat is dropped, it remains dropped, even if a transitive defeat which
> had caused it to be dropped is later eliminated."
... a sentence like this one is superfluous.
Matthias Urlichs    |    noris network AG    |    http://smurf.noris.de/
To those who doubt the importance of careful mate selection, remember how
Adam wrecked a promising career.
					-- Charles Merrill Smith

Attachment: pgpAroovbs7Ou.pgp
Description: signature

Reply to: