Re: Condorcet Voting and Supermajorities (Re: [CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT] Disambiguation of 4.1.5)
On Thu, Nov 30, 2000 at 02:34:58AM +1000, Anthony Towns wrote:
> With your rule, you instead just have an initial vote, with the initial
> pairwise preferences:
>
> A dominates B, 60 to 40
> A dominates F, 100 to 10
> B dominates F, 100 to 10
What part of my proposed A.6 leads you to believe this? [It's other
parts of the constitution which specify how the ballots are constructed.]
> which are then scaled with supermajority requirements to be:
>
> B dominates A, 40 to 20
> A dominates F, 33.3 to 10
> B dominates F, 100 to 10
>
> and B wins by dominating all other options.
Supermajority doesn't apply on votes which are not final votes,
since they won't be ammending the constitution.
--
Raul
Reply to: