[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: transfer speed data



On Wed, Dec 23, 2020 at 05:09:47PM +0100, Nicolas George wrote:
Michael Stone (12020-12-23):
No, network speeds are traditionally measured in bits because networks
transferred data in bits and telcos dealt with bits, and they sold and
billed bits. Computer internals were measured in bytes and words because
they transferred data in bytes and words. Some people do now talk about
network speeds for computers in byte units, but you're really just swapping
one source of confusion for another when you do that. (There's an immense
amount of existing tooling for network-related information that already uses
bits, so everything that decides bytes are better for networking requires
conversion when dealing with most other networking tools even if it
eliminates conversion when dealing with filesystem or memory tools.) There
isn't one "right answer" that magically simplifies communications.

I read this paragraph as the defense of a cargo cult.

You may certainly read it as you wish, nevertheless I'll continue to explain why things are measured in different ways in different domains without resorting to baseless conspiracy theories. I'm also mostly interested in communicating with actual people, so regardless of whether you believe you have a superior approach that is more logical than the way language is used by other people is irrelevant to me--I find it more productive to be as clear as possible within the bounds of common usage than to insist that everyone else should change. YMMV, have fun with your crusade.


Reply to: