[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Laptop choice?



Don't buy an HP/Compaq.  Two reasons:

1.  They never perform as good as the hardware suggest.  This has been
my observation over several years dealing with clients who buy nothing
but HP.

2.  HP of late has a filthy habit of boobytrapping their notebooks to
not take generic components.  My nx6125, for example, will not work with
any hard disc other than the 80GB Seagate (with HP firmware) that it
came with.  Sure you can put something else in, but it simply disables
DMA making it hardly usable.  This leaves you with two problems.  If you
run out of space, you can't put something bigger in, and b) if your disc
dies after the warranty ran out, you're going to pay through your nose
for a new drive.  I can also not replace the wireless min-PCI card.
Mine shipped with a broadcom.  At the time, ndiswrapper was quite
unstable, so I put an Atheros card in that I scavanged from an AP.
Notebook wouln't even post - says something like "Unsupported PCI
device, please remove."  I thought, OK, I'll buy one from HP - got an HP
branded Intel 2200 card (which was listed as compatible with my
notebook) - same story.

Hans makes good points about the HP.  However, I recently bought a
nice hp laptop and installed etch without incident.  Looks like, based
upon Hans' insight, that I could have trouble down the road if I want
to upgrade some components.

Here's the main details of my machine.  It was 1300$ but has a very
rad processor, 2GB memory, and a 17 inch wide screen monitor.  The
ethernet card is didn't work with the sarge installer but worked fine
with the etch net-installer.  The graphics card did install but was
suboptimal until I got the beta version of the driver from NVIDIA,
which was a piece of cake to install.  So far, the machine appears to
be blazing fast and great to look at ( good monitor ).  However, I am
concerned about the issues that Hans raised.

HP dv9000t

Intel(R) Core(TM) 2 Duo processor T7200 (2.0 GHz)
256MB NVIDIA(R) GeForce(R) Go 7600
Intel(R) PRO/Wireless 3945ABG Network Connection
intel pro 1000 ethernet card



Reply to: