[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Name server choices?



[This list is migthy verbose, so please respond both to the list and myself
directly.]

I'm about to transition the DNS server from one Debian stable machine to
another. The current configuration is a chroot hack on top of the normal
bind package.

I'm thinking this transition would be a great time to investigate the
alternative to bind. Bind, as I understand it, is notoriously buggy and
insecure. (thus the chroot)

A few apt-cache searches later, and I turn up the following alternatives:

maradns - A simple DNS server, aimed to be secure (http://www.maradns.org/)
djbdns-installer - Source only package for building djbdns (http://cr.yp.to/djbdns.html)

I am a bit suprised. I expected a plethora of choices. :-\

maradns appears to be several versions behind (stable: 0.9.15-1) and after
surfing its homepage I wonder about its feature completeness and production
readiness. In short, maradns makes me nervous.

djbdns seems like a great alternative, except it's not DFSG compliant.
Normally, this doesn't phase me. However, for our DNS server I would like
the peace of mind to know the software can and will be supported in the
future. Supposedly there have been no security bugs found thus far - but
offering a reward seems to me would discourage rather than encourage takers.
In short, djbdns makes me nervous too.

Are there any other options I'm missing? Is there a reason for a lack of DNS
servers in the open source world? At the very least, I'm suprised no one has
started a project to implement one in a managed language.

Thanks, in advnace, for your comments, advice and help!

Scott.

-- 
http://quadhome.com/            - Personal webpage
http://tranzoa.net/             - Corporate webpage

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: