Re: Root-on-LVM-on-RAID HOWTO
On Fri, Jan 10, 2003 at 12:02:20PM +0100, Massimiliano Ferrero wrote:
> I've written a doc on how to install a Debian with root file system over
> LVM and RAID.
> If it's of any interest it can be found at this URL:
> Any suggestion/criticism/correction is welcome.
A few things:
o Please mention that the HOWTO is i386 specific. I recently used
some ideas from your HOWTO to do something similar on a sparc, but it
was painful :-) i had to use a non-RAID /boot to do it.
o Perhaps this was just me, but the default debian install starts both
LVM and RAID at S25 in /etc/rcS.d . If you aren't using raid
autodetect this can cause problems because LVM starts first. I moved
LVM to S27.
o I noticed you use bash in your initrd; wouldn't ash be more
appropriate? Also, insmod/modprobe aren't needed when the kernel has
RAID and LVM compiled in.
o Another initrd point: it's important to note that the filesystem of
the initrd needs to be writable so vgscan works. The first time
around I used cramfs ... oops. You also need to leave enough free
space so vgscan and vgchange can write their stuff, or you should
provide "-A n" to vgchange so it doesn't write a backup. Since the
initrd gets pivoted out of the way writing a backup seems like a waste
o I found it a lot easier to just use mdadm to set up my RAID; I
didn't bother creating a raidtab at all. I have no spare disks so I
don't need one.
That's all I can remember right now :-)
Nathan Norman - Incanus Networking mailto:email@example.com
A right is not what someone gives you; it's what no one can take
-- Ramsey Clark