[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#309548: Dummy run: upgrade of aptitude will remove perl



Package: upgrade-reports

I just did a dry-run of a woody->sarge upgrade as a test for the release 
notes.

I made sure my Woody environment was fully up-to-date.
The system does contain some unofficial packages:
- KDE 3.2.0-0woody1 (from download.kde.org)
- OpenOffice1.1 1.1beta2-2 (from www.fs.tum.de/~bunk)
- Various backports: subversion, automake, gettext
- Self-compiled from CVS: kdevelop, vlc

I wanted to upgrade to sarge's aptitude before the main dist-upgrade and 
tried different combinations:
  Method                                Upgrade  New inst  Remove  Held
- aptitude install aptitude dpkg           60       35       128    565
- apt-get  install aptitude dpkg           61       52       111    575

Among the things to be removed were:
- perl and a lot of perl-related packages
- autoconf, automake, devscripts, dpkg-dev
- gs (ghostscript)
- kde development packages
- openoffice

On a hunch I tried:
  Method                                Upgrade  New inst  Remove  Held
- aptitude install aptitude dpkg perl      65       82        26    655
- apt-get  install aptitude dpkg perl      65       91        21    658

This left only some (obsolete?) perl packages and OpenOffice to be 
removed; a much more satisfying result.

So it looks as if we need the upgrade instructions to be somewhat 
flexible: see if important packages will be removed and try adding them 
in the initial upgrade.

Question
I thought an issue with unwanted removal of perl had been resolved?

Cheers,
FJP

Attachment: packages.lst.gz
Description: GNU Zip compressed data

Attachment: pgpSDBdy7cP75.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Reply to: