On Thu, Sep 30, 2004 at 12:31:11PM +0200, Martin Schulze wrote: > Jeroen van Wolffelaar wrote: > > On Mon, Sep 27, 2004 at 11:38:02PM +0200, Adrian Bunk wrote: > > > Package: education-common > > > Version: 0.801 > > > Severity: serious > > > education-common recommends grub which is available only on i386. > > education-common is an arch: all package, therefore, it is technically > > impossible to have an arch-specific Recommends: > > Because this bug isn't one used as a reason for britney to keep a package out > > of testing, and the package is otherwise installable, this package is now in > > Sarge. > > Release Managers, what do you think of this bug? > > 1) Do you agree it is RC? > > - I'm personally tending to say: yes. If a package is installable on an > > arch, it should also be able to fulfil recommends. Post-sarge, all > > packages that are not installable on certain archs should not be in the > > Packages.gz files for their uninstallable archs, or something analogous > > to that > > 2) How should it be resolved? > > - Personal favourite, make this package arch:any, and have per architecture > > the needed boot loader for that architecture. I think any > > moderately-complex meta-package that depends on very architecture > > dependent stuff (I.e., hardware specific drivers, kernels and > > bootloaders) should be architecture: any, to be able to have > > architecture-dependent package relations. Maybe this part of > > education-common should be split out into education-boot, so that only > > that package needs to be any, but that's something the debian-edu folks > > should decide. > I'd rather investigate why education-common needs to recommend grub at all. > The name makes me think that it's a "task" package, basically consisting > on dependencies. Does it need to have a dependency to grub at all? Quite agreed. If there were a clearer reason for having such a recommends, I'm not sure it would be RC (but I'd have to see such a case to know for sure); here, it seems the relationship should definitely be dropped. -- Steve Langasek postmodern programmer
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature