Bug#535359: excuses.php is confused about ICU
reassign 535359 bugs.debian.org
On Wed, Jul 01, 2009 at 05:51:09PM -0400, Jay Berkenbilt wrote:
> (sorry, resending with Package pseudoheader. Duh.)
> (Release team: ICU 4.0.1-3 might need a hint to transition to testing
> once its 10 days are up...see below for details.)
> Whatever excuses.php calls (update-excuses?) is confused about RC bug
> 530568, reported against the experimental version of ICU. It now seems
> to think that transitioning ICU to testing will introduce this bug, but
> this bug does not apply to the unstable version. Maybe the confusion is
> because the unstable version is newer in time than the experimental
> version, but I haven't looked at the code.
> Here is an abbreviated chronology:
> 1. 2009-05-25: RC bug 530568 was reported against ICU 4.2-1 (experimental)
> 2. 2009-06-27: Version 4.0.1-3 uploaded to unstable
> 3. 2009-06-28: bug 530568 closed for version 4.2.1~rc1-3
> (experimental) and also explicitly marked "notfound" in 4.0.1-3
> http://qa.debian.org/excuses.php?package=icu reports
> Excuse for icu
> * Too young, only 4 of 10 days old
> * icu (source) has new bugs!
> * Updating icu introduces new bugs: #530568
> * Not considered
> In fact, updating ICU does not introduce new RC bugs. I imagine that
> there is either a problem in the excuses code or that I have done
> something wrong with respect to telling the BTS which versions of the
> package contain this bug. It seems to me that the logic should be that,
> if a bug applies to version X, it should apply automatically to version
> Y if Y > X, not if Y was uploaded more recently than X. But I'm only
> guessing about the age anyway since I haven't looked at the code.
This is the second time in recent weeks that I've seen such a case of
britney mis-reporting a package in unstable as RC buggy. I think there's a
regression here in the bug lists that bugs.debian.org is feeding to britney.
Steve Langasek Give me a lever long enough and a Free OS
Debian Developer to set it on, and I can move the world.
Ubuntu Developer http://www.debian.org/