Bug#1096826: icon: ftbfs with GCC-15
On Tue, Sep 09, 2025 at 12:33:55PM +0200, Mechtilde Stehmann wrote:
> This problem should be fixed with the upload of version 9.5.25a
>
> As Matthias wrote the bug report will only be closed after the next test
> rebuild.
Please don't do that. This is a common misconception.
This is the paragraph you refer:
"Please keep the issue open until the package can be built in
a follow-up test rebuild."
and the meaning is: Please close the bug only when the issue is solved
(usually in unstable), at which point an *hypothetical* test rebuild
would not flag the package as failing anymore.
This is about reproducibility of the fix in a scientific sense
(i.e. when the package is fixed, everybody should be able to check
that it's fixed).
Matthias does not make follow-up test rebuilds "to see if the issue is
fixed", and will not tell anybody "this is now fixed, you can close
the bug now". (And that's completely ok, he already has enough work
to do).
It is still the maintainer's responsibility to verify that the issue
is solved, closing the bug when it is.
Usually, you would do that by using the Closes keyword in the
changelog, as always.
Cc: Matthias. Could you please reword the problematic paragraph for
your next mass bug filing? Believe it or not, this is at least the
third time that I see a misunderstanding about it.
Thanks.
Reply to: