[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#66535: Proposal of requirements for packages providing system-log-daemon or kernel-log-daemon



Hello.

Martin, I'm waiting for your response since spring, I'll NMU
sysklogd soon ...

----- for policy:
system-log-daemon: Reads messages from /dev/log and provides
syslog-facility. Conflicts with other system-log-daemons.

kernel-log-daemon: Reads messages from /proc/kmsg or per ioctl
and writes them to /dev/log. Conflicts with kernel-log-daemon.
-----

They need to conflict with themselfes, because:
o Many provide identical files (/etc/syslog.conf,
  /sbin/syslog-facility), alternatives are not applicable because
  of the fast differences in formats and interfaces.
o More than one instance of a daemon can only be run with
  special configuration (and can be avoided), else they would
  read or write the same sockets, which would lead to chaos.

May be the interface of syslog-facility should get formalized,
or at least frozen.

A nice thing to do would be to split the sysklogd package into a
syslogd and a klogd part. This would allow syslog-ng to use
klogd without a Replaces: (I consider the current situation a
cludge).

ciao, 2ri
-- 
Der beste Beweis für die Existenz ausserirdischer _Intelligenz_
ist der, dass noch niemand versucht hat, Kontakt mit uns
aufzunehmen.
			-- Bill Watterson

Attachment: pgpjFJSQob7pT.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Reply to: