[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Bug#845018: RFS: quagga/1.1.0-1 [ITA] -- network routing daemons



On 2016-11-26.15:48, Vincent Bernat wrote:
>  ❦ 22 novembre 2016 23:55 +1100, Scott Leggett <scott@sl.id.au> :
> 
> > This is now ready, here are the changes since your last review:
> >
> > * Add automatic migration from -dbg to -dbgsym.
> > * Add users/groups unconditionally to simplify preinst.
> > * Create "quagga" metapackage.
> 
> I would have removed the recommends for quagga-core package as it would
> make more difficult for most people to only keep the daemons they need
> and do not bring anything sensible compared to quagga/quagga-core
> packages. Of course, that's quite subjective.
> 

You're right - I've changed this to make the daemon packages Suggests
rather than Recommends.

> > * Use debhelper integration with dpkg-maintscript-helper.
> > * Remove /etc/default/quagga.
> 
> Should be removed with dpkg-maintscript-helper to alert the user there
> was a change (and its modifications are now ignored).
> 

Actually this file is not in the current quagga package - I added it
during my adoption of the package but have now removed it again.

> You could also remove README.Maintainer if it doesn't contain any
> relevant information. There are also some bits of the README.Debian
> about SNMP that are not up-to-date (some sentences just need to be
> removed).
>

I updated README.Debian to remove references to old Debian releases.
I'd like to keep README.Maintainer though, just because I did actually
find it useful during adoption and I've added some more packaging notes
in there. It doesn't end up in any package anyway - just in the
repository.

> Other than that, all is OK.

Great! New packages are up at https://mentors.debian.net/package/quagga

Changes since your last review:

  * Make daemon packages Suggests rather than Recommends of quagga-core.
  * Remove reference to old Debian release in README.Debian.
  * Avoid VCS files in packages.

-- 
Regards,
Scott.

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: