[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#828889: RFS: elisp-slime-nav-el/0.9-1 ITP



> I thought you were finished after evil and its dependencies :)  Glad to
> see more ELPA packages. Here's a review for you.

Thank you. There are still dependencies of my .emacs that are not in
Debian.

> 1. The "-el" suffix on the source package name is pointless because the
>    name already contains "elisp" so it's clear that it's an Emacs
>    package.  Please consider dropping the suffix.  On the Emacsen team
>    we use upstream names where possible.

Done.

> 2. Have you forwarded 0001-Fix-Package-Version-header.patch upstream?

Upstream not interested. Melpa generates version from git tag.

> 3. Please patch README.md to remove the installation instructions (might
>    be confusing to someone who has already installed the package) and
>    remove the MELPA badges from the top (useless in plain text).

Done.

> 4. No pristine-tar branch is available.  For the sake of the sponsorship
>    process it might be worth adding one.

Should be there, but binary files in git make me uneasy.

-- 
Accept: text/plain, text/x-diff
Accept-Language: eo,en,ru
X-Web-Site: sinsekvu.github.io


Reply to: