[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: ghdl package has been removed from Mentors



On 2014-07-19, mentors.debian.net wrote:
> Your package ghdl all versions has been removed from
> mentors.debian.net for the following reason:
> 
> Your package found no sponsor for 20 weeks

Ok.

This comes as a bit of a surprise, and it may be unfortunate. My idea
was that, even if no sponsor would be found, at least
mentors.debian.net would reflect the latest state of development of the
package, possibly as a starting point for further work. By removing the
package, you have made my work unavailable for the world, and you have
also deleted any comments that were posted by prospective sponsors.

On the other hand, it is true that I have essentially given up on
attempts to get my package into the distribution. I can understand that
you want to focus mentors.debian.net on work which is actively
developed, and not let it become a dumping ground for half-finished
stuff.

Fair enough. I will simply move the packaging files back to my personal
website.

Two points which I think you should consider:

* A little warning ahead of time would be nice before you delete stuff.
  I don't see your 20-weeks rule in the Q&A, for example.

* If I follow the URL to my (now deleted) package page, I would expect
  an error message saying that the packgage does not currently exist.
  Instead, the server silently redirects me to the list of packages.

  That is not helpful. If something goes completely wrong inside a
  computer, it is important to tell the user about it. There is this
  misguided notion that users dislike error messages, therefore
  software should never report errors. Please don't believe that.

Kind regards,
Joris.

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature


Reply to: