> George Danchev wrote: >> * Generally, your sponsor(s) would want to test the packages, however >> that would need certain home automation infrastructure to be in place >> which is not available everywhere, so you might need to suggest a way >> to simulate their operation if that is easily possible. OK, I'd better check the log of the mailinglist, since I'm not subscribed to debian-mentors anymore. > I'm not a DD but I would tend to reduce the problem to a nice-to-have > and not see it as a show-stopper: when I package a library, I'm pretty > sure that my sponsors don't check that they work, but only that they > compile properly and are in accordance with the Debian policy(ies). > > Anyway, as maintainer, it's me receiving the bug reports, so I better > make sure that it works ;-) Functionality wise: 1. I'm pretty certain that the function of KNX/EIB is working since I'm doing nothing more than packaging well established products (in fact, eibd is a subset of the full functionality. I don't want to package all of it in a first phase since the compiler requires a lot more dependencies that are not available on the target platforms for automation (not x86 processors). On top of that; it provides functionality that I would not want to make available to anyone: you don't want to have a series of lights or heatings bricked in your house. 2. package wise; you can just install it and everything should be started as expected. I believe that this would even be the case if you do not have an IP gateway to your KNX bus (though I'd have to check that). linknx dependes on eibd-server running; that's enforced in the start scripts. 3. You could 'simulate' startup behaviour by manually installing a eibd-server and letting the test system connect to the eibd-server you just started. Again probably; since I haven't tested this. 4. And even if all this should be true; I see little point in doing this: the KNX devices are so heterogeneous and any system is so different from the other that full functionality test is impossible unless you have a fully configured and customised system. The best I can do is to provide a very extensive example xml file that people can use. I do agree that it might be good into investigating in having a 'dummy' IP KNX gateway; only for packaging; otherwise it would be pretty pointless. -- greetz, marc The Universe is populated by stable things. -- Richard Dawkins crichton 2.6.26 #1 PREEMPT Tue Jul 29 21:17:59 CDT 2008 GNU/Linux
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature