Re: Suggests vs. Recommends
On Fri, 03 Aug 2007, Benjamin Mesing wrote:
> As for 'packagesearch', even if no additional package is installed,
> there is always the full text search available - so the package by
> itself is useful. Thus there is no need to *Depends:* on deborphan
> or apt-file. Also, I could imagine a 'usual' installation (compare
> [2#Recommends]) without those packages installed, so this would hint
> for *Suggests:*.
That's pretty much the judgement call that has to be made.
In the default case where someone has installed packagesearch, would
they expect the file search and/or orphaned package plugins to work?
You get to make a judgement one way or the other; if a significant
population of your users complain that the Recommends: isn't necessary
(or vice versa, that they expected the functionality not present
because you made it a Suggests:) then you know that you should switch
The sheer ponderousness of the panel's opinion ... refutes its thesis
far more convincingly than anything I might say. The panel's labored
effort to smother the Second Amendment by sheer body weight has all
the grace of a sumo wrestler trying to kill a rattlesnake by sitting
on it--and is just as likely to succeed.
-- Alex Kozinski in Silveira V Lockyer