Bug#785353: lintian: RfC: retiring hyphen-used-as-minus-sign
Control: tags -1 pending
On 2015-05-16 03:21, Russ Allbery wrote:
> [...]
> Pedantic would be the appropriate spot for this. However....
>
>> Jakub Wilk wrote:
>>> Yeah, these days even upstream groff renders both - and \- as
>>> HYPHEN-MINUS.
>
>> Then again, this sounds as if it's indeed obsolete. Actually I can
>> imagine easily the semantic difference, but I've never noticed any
>> different rendering. But then again I'd expect no difference with any
>> rendering in text-mode and I never read man-pages in graphical tools.
>
> ...basically, historically, there was a difference between - and \-. But
> I think absolutely everyone has given up on this, including groff
> upstream, and at this point we're just poking random upstreams about
> something that they don't care about and don't have any real defensible
> reason to care about. Or carrying really tedious and hard-to-maintain
> diffs.
>
> I think we should just drop it.
>
> However, copying Colin, as I think he should weigh in on this as man-db
> maintainer and groff maintainer.
>
Hi,
Given Colin did not seem to have any remarks to this, I have decided to
commit the change.
Thanks,
~Niels
Reply to: