Request for help in checking GPL-compatibility
Dear people,
Please tell me gently if I am in the wrong place to ask this question.
I would like to know whether the Swiss Ephemeris Public Licence which
can be found at:
ftp://astro.com/pub/swisseph/src/LICENSE
is GPL-compatible or not. That is, can I write a program based on this
library and GPL it? As I read it, it is GPL-compatible. But for
verification I asked the FSF people to check it, and though they did not
give an official approval/disapproval, they said they "thought" it would
not be compatible because it is based on the QPL. Of course this reply
was from a volunteer and not from any authority at FSF.
I pointed out to them that the SEPL does not have the "modifications to
be redistributed as patches only" restriction which is the basic problem
with the QPL, but after that I did not get any reply from them at all.
I would really like to use this library (Swiss Ephemeris) but I have to
GPL my program since I use Qt OSS edition. I asked the people who wrote
and hence own the library whether I can GPL a program based on their
library but they said no "because it would allow commercial use of the
library which is not permitted by the SEPL". Again I feel they have
confused commercial software and proprietary software.
So I request and hope that the good people here help me reach a decision
- whether the SEPL is GPL-compatible or not. If it is not, please tell
me what is the problem.
Also when a licence is GPL-compatible it is also automatically
DFSG-compatible, right?
Thanks.
Shriramana Sharma.
Reply to: