Ying-Chun Liu (PaulLiu) escribe: > By ears, there's no difference between mp3 and wav It depends on the ears, certainly. It also depends on the bitrate chosen for the MP3 file and also on the audio outboard used (at 128 Kbps there's no difference with a portable player but the difference becomes obvious with top class speakers). > The same thing also happens on images, like xcf/psd or png/jpg/gif or > whatever. But the author should release the true source he really has. > To require the author to use some listed formats for image source or > audio source is impracticable. And if we define ogg/mp3 is not source, > the games which have ogg/mp3 as data but cannot provide wav (may be > deleted by the author by nature) will be non-free due to DFSG#2. Agreed. If the author used MPEG-4 video files as the source it makes no sense forcing him to share them in MJPEG format. Also if he remixed MP3 files, why forcing to share FLAC or WAV? There will be no gain. "The author should release the true source he really has". That's the point IMHO. Cordially, Ismael -- Ismael Valladolid Torres m. +34679156321 La media hostia j. ivalladt@gmail.com http://lamediahostia.blogspot.com/
Attachment:
pgpjkGSkykObl.pgp
Description: PGP signature