Re: GPL and command-line libraries
On Mon, Dec 06, 2004 at 12:51:34AM -0500, Anthony DeRobertis wrote:
> A compiler can only perform a transformation from source to object form
> programmed into it by its creators; it is neither an author nor capable
> of creativity; it can this not produce an original work of authorship or
> thus a derivative work.
> If A is derivative work of B, then the compiled form A' is probably too.
> If A is not a derivative work of B, then A' is not either.
I seem to recall someone arguing that A' containing inlined functions
from B would constitute a form of "derivation". At least distributing A'
would also be distributing parts compiled from B.
* Customer: "My palmtop won't turn on."
* Tech Support: "Did the battery run out, maybe?"
* Customer: "No, it doesn't use batteries. It's Windows powered."