Re: Squeak in Debian?
"Lex Spoon" <firstname.lastname@example.org> wrote:
> Walter Landry <email@example.com> wrote:
> > > BUT, we are only obligated to the extent the case deals with our own
> > > actions. I do not see a problem with this. That seems good and proper
> > > to stand up for our own actions. The clause does *NOT* make us liable
> > > for all legal attacks on Apple regarding Squeak.
> > J. Random CD distributor on Battlestar Galactica distributes a copy of
> > Squeak to his fellow argonauts. The Silons sue Apple for contributory
> > copyright infringement, citing the distribution by J. Random. Now
> > J. Random is obligated to defend Apple in US court, even though
> > J. Random doesn't even know where Earth is.
> J. Random CD distributor is irrelevant to this discussion. Squeak would
> be in non-free, where it's user beware and distributor beware.
Ah, I thought you were still contesting the main/non-free distinction.
In any case, non-free is not entirely distributor beware. CD
manufacturers have to be careful, but mirrors do not. I don't believe
that any other license in non-free has this kind of clause, though I'm
open to being proven wrong.
> > > I do not understand your issue about locality. The business in question
> > > is us, Debian. We already have a distribution server at Berkeley, so we
> > > already need to evaluate and comply with the laws of northern
> > > California.
> > The CD distributors are not part of SPI, the non-profit that holds
> > title to the vast resources of Debian. In addition, the Debian
> > mirrors only look at local law when evaluating whether to mirror
> > Debian. They don't look up Northern California law.
> The individual CD distributors should not be automatically distributing
> non-free stuff. Thus I still do not see the issue.
> It seems like our non-free infrastructure already needs to obey US
> export law, so I do not see the issue with us meeting that license
non-free is not part of the bxa notification scheme, because the bxa
notifications is only available for certain type of software of which
main is a subset. So there are still packages in non-us/non-free.