Bug#136659: gcc: optimisation on sparc leads to unalligned access in memcpy
Package: gcc
Version: 1:2.95.2-13
Severity: normal
To add to my problem (reported on debian devel) here is a test program to
reproduce it:
Output with o=2 (unaligned)
ecki@auric:~$ ./bla
Start of struct 0xeffffc70, content: a=aaaaaaaaaaaaaa rel-pos x=12 offset
o=2
Now we are going to memcpy dst=a+x+o=0xeffffc7e
result of a+x+o access: b=aaaabbbbbbbbbb
Now we are going to bcopy dst=&(tmp_iphdr->saddr)=0xeffffc7e
result of bcopy &(tmp_iphdr->saddr) access: b=aaaabbbbbbbbbb
Now we are going to memcpy dst=&(tmp_iphdr->saddr)=0xeffffc7e
Bus error
Output with o=4 (aligned)
ecki@auric:~$ gcc -O2 -o bla bla.c
ecki@auric:~$ ./bla
Start of struct 0xeffffc70, content: a=aaaaaaaaaaaaaa rel-pos x=12 offset
o=4
Now we are going to memcpy dst=a+x+o=0xeffffc80
result of a+x+o access: b=aaaabbbbbbbbbb
Now we are going to bcopy dst=&(tmp_iphdr->saddr)=0xeffffc80
result of bcopy &(tmp_iphdr->saddr) access: b=aaaabbbbbbbbbb
Now we are going to memcpy dst=&(tmp_iphdr->saddr)=0xeffffc80
result of memcpy &(tmp_iphdr->saddr) access: b=aaaabbbbbbbbbb
Note: in both cases the pointer to the target (of bcopy and memcpy) are the
same a+x+o=0xeffffc7e and &(tmp_iphdr->saddr)=0xeffffc7e. The first case
works with memcpy, the second doesnt. This looks clearly like some broken
optimization.
Indeed:
ecki@auric:~$ gcc -O0 -o bla bla.c
ecki@auric:~$ ./bla
Start of struct 0xeffffc70, content: a=aaaaaaaaaaaaaa rel-pos x=12 offset
o=2
Now we are going to memcpy dst=a+x+o=0xeffffc7e
result of a+x+o access: b=aaaabbbbbbbbbb
Now we are going to bcopy dst=&(tmp_iphdr->saddr)=0xeffffc7e
result of bcopy &(tmp_iphdr->saddr) access: b=aaaabbbbbbbbbb
Now we are going to memcpy dst=&(tmp_iphdr->saddr)=0xeffffc7e
result of memcpy &(tmp_iphdr->saddr) access: b=aaaabbbbbbbbbb
I guess this means I should report a bug against gcc
-- System Information
Debian Release: 2.2
Kernel Version: Linux auric 2.4.15-pre4 #1 SMP Thu Nov 15 09:26:46 EST 2001
sparc64 unknown
Versions of the packages gcc depends on:
ii binutils 2.10.0.9-4 The GNU assembler, linker and binary utiliti
ii cpp 2.95.2-13 The GNU C preprocessor.
ii libc6 2.1.3-20 GNU C Library: Shared libraries and Timezone
Reply to: