[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#225692: (Bug 225692) The patch provided is just like the one I provided (!?)



Hi, I'm just curious because reviewing this bug it looks like the patch
provided by Scoot is _precisely_ the same patch I provided (albeit with the
comments describing the behaviour removed). As I mentioned in the bug
report, the code I provided was taken verbatim from remove.c (well, it has
been reindented but it's exaclty the same code).

Reviewing the NMU I can see that the applied patch does not include any of 
the comments I provided (nor references) which, I believe, gave appropiate 
credit. After all, Brian Hatch found this issue first (even if he did not 
report it himself).

Is there any reason why my comments (and the debug line I added) have been 
removed from the patch? 

Regards

Javier

PS: Giving credit would have been also a nice thing, BTW.
PPS: I would have liked to hear dpkg-dev's team input in this issue, 
changes in this package are of significant importance that I did not want 
to risk doing an NMU.
PPS: CCing me in the replies to Erno would have been nice too.

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: