Re: Minified files and source code requirement
Russ Allbery wrote:
> I think a better line is whether the source tarball includes all the
> pieces required for someone with appropriate skills to make modifications
> to the software with reasonable ease. The advantage of that, as opposed
> to trying to weigh whether upstream has additional advantages, is that
> it's a judgement call that can be made solely based on the contents of the
> source tarball without reference to anything external.
Do we agree that minified Javascript libraries do not meet this
criterion (for non-broken definitions of "reasonable")? If so, I'd
leave the other theoretical cases for until someone proposes an
appropriate wording for a change to the constitution or policy (so
then we can have the shared goal of debugging that wording[*]).
If not, of course, that point of disagreement seems like a good place
to focus the discussion.
Hope that helps,
Jonathan
[*] of course, the current wording ("The program must include source
code") is buggy because vague. But that's harder to debug without an
example people disagree about.
Reply to: