trouble sending email with caff (pgp-tools / signing-party)

To: debian-devel@lists.debian.org
Subject: trouble sending email with caff (pgp-tools / signing-party)
From: "Tim Olsen" <tolsen718@gmail.com>
Date: Mon, 8 May 2006 13:56:12 -0400
Message-id: <[🔎] 4be80d840605081056k4cedfd47h8442906c1874d298@mail.gmail.com>

Hello,

I am trying to use caff send signed keys from a key-signing party.caff successfully signs each key but some of the emails are refused

because the receiver's server fails to verify the sender.

My MTA is set to receive and send mail on its own; however, it is
behind a firewall so the actual sender's address is not routeable
(I've set the From address to be a routeable address).  This does not
cause a problem with my usual mail.  I can send mail to outside
addresses just fine.

I believe the problem may stem from perl's mailtools library setting
the Sender: field.  My usual mail does not have this problem.

I am attaching the bounce message and a successfully sent email to my
gmail address.  You'll see that the original email in the bounce
message has a Sender: field and the email sent to my gmail address
does not.

Is this something that should be fixed in perl's mailtools or is my
MTA setup not kosher?  I prefer to have my MTA send mail because my
internal networks smart host is overloaded.

thanks,
Tim

>From MAILER-DAEMON Mon May 08 13:29:37 2006
Return-path: <>
Envelope-to: tim@lemonchord.limewire.com
Delivery-date: Mon, 08 May 2006 13:29:37 -0400
Received: from Debian-exim by lemonchord.limewire.com with local (Exim 4.62)
	id 1Fd9Y9-0007nf-Bc
	for tim@lemonchord.limewire.com; Mon, 08 May 2006 13:29:37 -0400
X-Failed-Recipients: mako@debian.org,
  tolsen@alum.mit.edu
Auto-Submitted: auto-replied
From: Mail Delivery System <Mailer-Daemon@lemonchord.limewire.com>
To: tim@lemonchord.limewire.com
Subject: Mail delivery failed: returning message to sender
Message-Id: <E1Fd9Y9-0007nf-Bc@lemonchord.limewire.com>
Date: Mon, 08 May 2006 13:29:37 -0400
Status: RO
Content-Length: 5592
Lines: 110

This message was created automatically by mail delivery software.

A message that you sent could not be delivered to one or more of its
recipients. This is a permanent error. The following address(es) failed:

  mako@debian.org
    SMTP error from remote mail server after RCPT TO:<mako@debian.org>:
    host master.debian.org [146.82.138.7]: 550-Verification failed for <tim@lemonchord.limewire.com>
    550-Unrouteable address
    550 Sender verify failed
  tolsen@alum.mit.edu
    SMTP error from remote mail server after MAIL FROM:<tim@lemonchord.limewire.com> SIZE=5859:
    host ALUM-2.mit.edu [18.7.21.145]: 553 5.1.8 <tim@lemonchord.limewire.com>... Domain of sender address tim@lemonchord.limewire.com does not exist

------ This is a copy of the message, including all the headers. ------

Return-path: <tim@lemonchord.limewire.com>
Received: from tim by lemonchord.limewire.com with local (Exim 4.62)
	(envelope-from <tim@lemonchord.limewire.com>)
	id 1Fd9Y6-0007nZ-31; Mon, 08 May 2006 13:29:34 -0400
MIME-Version: 1.0
Subject: Your signed PGP key 0x89CD4B21607559E6
User-Agent: caff 0.0.0.278 - http://pgp-tools.alioth.debian.org/
X-Mailer: MIME-tools 5.420 (Entity 5.420)
Sender: "Tim Olsen,,," <tim@lemonchord.limewire.com>
Content-Type: multipart/encrypted;
 protocol="application/pgp-encrypted";
 boundary="----------=_1147109373-29937-1"
To: mako@debian.org
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
From: "Timothy Olsen" <tolsen@alum.mit.edu>
Message-Id: <E1Fd9Y6-0007nZ-31@lemonchord.limewire.com>
Date: Mon, 08 May 2006 13:29:34 -0400

This is a multi-part message in MIME format...

------------=_1147109373-29937-1
Content-Type: application/pgp-encrypted
Content-Disposition: attachment
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

Version: 1

------------=_1147109373-29937-1
Content-Type: application/octet-stream; name="msg.asc"
Content-Disposition: inline; filename="msg.asc"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

-----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.3 (GNU/Linux)
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=lLlh
-----END PGP MESSAGE-----

------------=_1147109373-29937-1--

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               
Received-SPF: pass (gmail.com: domain of tim@lemonchord.limewire.com designates 216.27.158.74 as permitted sender)
Date: Mon, 8 May 2006 12:38:06 -0400
From: Tim Olsen <tolsen@limewire.com>
To: tolsen718@gmail.com
Subject: test
Message-ID: <20060508163806.GB24799@lemonchord.limewire.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.11+cvs20060403


testing 235

-- 
-----------------------------------------------
"We were after the C++ programmers. We managed
to drag a lot of them about halfway to Lisp."

- Guy Steele, co-author of the Java spec

Reply to:

Follow-Ups:
- Re: trouble sending email with caff (pgp-tools / signing-party)
  - From: Peter Palfrader <weasel@debian.org>

Prev by Date: Re: screenshot with package description
Next by Date: Re: Bug#366328: ITP: bsp -- nodes builder for doom-engine levels
Previous by thread: Re: Bug#366426: ITP: bcm43xx-fwcutter -- bcm43xx firmware extraction utility
Next by thread: Re: trouble sending email with caff (pgp-tools / signing-party)
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread