[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: namespace conflict != package Conflict?

Steve Greenland <steveg@moregruel.net> wrote:
> On 12-Jun-05, 02:27 (CDT), Hamish Moffatt <hamish@debian.org> wrote: 
> > >From my reading of your package description for cogito,
> > the name GIT (the version control system) doesn't seem to
> > mean anything in particular. So renaming it would not be a big loss.
> The upstream name isn't going to change. There are probably already
> more users of GIT-the-VCS than GIT-the-tools. So if you rename git for
> Debian, we are very likely going to to be incompatible.
> Just Conflict with the git package. The overlapping user base is likely
> to be nil.

There is at least one user that wants both...  I got a bug report about
this before I made cogito.deb Conflict with git.deb.  (Then of course
I was told that that was the wrong approach, so I _removed_ cogito's
/usr/bin/git and removed the Conflict with git.deb.)

But I agree totally with you.  I'd much rather conflict with GNU
Interactive Tools and have git-the-vcs be compatible with non-debian
universe.  That seems like the lesser of two evils.  But everyone else
on debian-devel seems to want it the other way so I gave in for now.

Sebastian Kuzminsky

Reply to: