[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: A Radical Multi-Arch Counter-Proposal



* Anthony DeRobertis (asd@suespammers.org) wrote:
> Proposal:
>      A. dpkg will be extended to support installing two packages with
>         the same name, but different ABIs, as previously proposed.

Yeah, so, you've already killed it, sorry.  Lots of assumptions in the
system based on single-package single-name, not to mention much more
complex for our users to have to deal with.

>      B. dpkg will be extended to support two packages with the same name
>         (as above) both owning the same file. It will only remove a file
>         from the filesystem when the last owning package is removed.

Uhhh, and if the files are different between the two packages?  What
about different versions of the packages?  I see below you're just going
to 'error out', there's a small problem there though, that's probably
going to be pretty often and that makes it not a reasonable thing to do.
Not to mention the added complexity to dpkg, bringing in lots of
opportunity for bugs and making life that much more confusing for our
users.

	Stephen

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: