[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#830978: Browserified javascript and DFSG 2



On 2016-07-13 16:26, Paul R. Tagliamonte wrote:
Traditionally, ftpteam has had to take this role, since it is the body
that decides if an upload is fit for main.

I am one of those folks that treat minified JS as binary, since things
like removing comments and renaming variables to `a`, `b` `c` is done.
Dead code can also be trimmed (closure compiler). In my mind it's not
hugely different than compiling nasm to an ELF. It may relate closely,
but it's not how you'd modify it.

Upstreams don't modify it in minified form. And just because you can
ghex an ELF to fix an asm bug, that doesn't make it the correct way
for us to ship code.

I haven't talked in-depth with the rest of the ftpteam, but I assume
they agree. CC'ing in case there's an objection.

Not completely sure why this was filed with TC

Because this isn't about minification. It's about collating multiple files into one, still resembling source code.

Kind regards
Philipp Kern


Reply to: