Re: Bug#342455: tech-ctte: Ownership and permissions of device mapper block devices
On Wed, Dec 14, 2005 at 01:54:45PM +0000, Ian Jackson wrote:
> Bastian Blank writes ("Re: Bug#342455: tech-ctte: Ownership and permissions of device mapper block devices"):
> > On Tue, Dec 13, 2005 at 03:55:01PM +0000, Ian Jackson wrote:
> > > [Raul Miller:]
> > > > 1) change devmapper defaults -- patch rejected, no reason given
> > > Certainly I agree that the defaults should be changed.
> > At least in my point of view, a default is something which can be
> > changed easily, maybe in a config file. In this case, it is no default,
> > it is the value which anything gets.
> You seem to be saying that there is no way to override the setting.
> Which proposed setting are you talking about here - the change in the
> call to configure, or some other change ?
> How do you think this problem should be solved ?
Add an interface to change the setting on device creation and delegate
the problem to the tools.
> > > > I've also seen the suggestion that we should have a explicit
> > > > technical policy that block devices should default to having 660
> > > > permissions with owner root and group disk. [...]
> > This breaks anything which wants to use group cdrom for cdrom access
> > without manual intervention.
> Obviously the policy language would have to be carefully worded to
> ensure that it applied to disks and not (eg) to cdrom devices.
devmapper don't provide disks. It provides a view (in the SQL meaning)
of block devices.
> Are you saying that the current default permissions on (eg) /dev/hda*
> are insecure and therefore wrong ?
Yes, I overwrite them on my machines.
> If they are, what significant good
> does it do to make the lvm devices inaccessible to group disk (since
> it is possible to avoid going through LVM to access the disks
deviver-mapper uses major and minor for the communication, only the
userspace tools uses the devices to read data or just map them to the
> Is the problem with your participation in this discussion that English
> isn't your native language ?
Yes, it is one.
Even historians fail to learn from history -- they repeat the same mistakes.
-- John Gill, "Patterns of Force", stardate 2534.7