[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#1098884: debian-installer: d-i in rescue mode: should give user more liberties with regards to partitioning drive



Hi,

Am 27. Februar 2025 12:58:46 MEZ schrieb Ralf Bergs <Ralf+Debian@Bergs.biz>:
>On 2025-02-25 15:37, Pascal Hambourg wrote:
>> On 25/02/2025 at 14:40, Ralf Bergs wrote:
>>> I wanted to repartition (delete all existing partitions) my drive in
>>> d-i in "rescue mode".
>>> 
>>> Unfortunately, d-i insisted that a root FS exists.
>>> 
>>> It would be helpful if this warning could be skipped, confirming "I
>>> want to do it anyway".
>> 
>> Rescue mode is not intended for using partman, d-i's partitioning interface. Instead it displays a screen where you can select which partition to mount and fix.
>Yes, I understand this. But does it not still make sense that some users want to use it for more low-level tasks, like I did when I just wanted to repartition the drive?

I don't think, such changing is likely to happen.
To perform such actions, you should use the normal installer mode.

>> If you just need to do simple partitioning such as deleting existing partitions, you can start a shell and use fdisk or parted.
>> 
>> In partman, "finish partitioning and write changes to disk" does not only create and format partitions (commit.d): it also checks if the setup is valid (check.d), mounts filesystems on selected mount points and writes some files such as /etc/fstab (finish.d). So check.d and finish.d would need to be skipped in rescue mode.
>Ok, *this* I was not aware of. So "partman" is not a generic "partition manager" (as I was assuming), but it is something with additional functionality included, *specifically* written "for" or "to support" d-i?

Yes, it's a specific module of debian-installer.

>> However a trick is to enter "Configure software RAID" (or LVM or encrypted volumes) instead; this will prompt to write pending changes on disk.
>Thanks. Now that you say it, I actually remember this behavior, but it's not obvious, especially for users like me who use d-i every couple of years only.
>
>What about an explicit menu item "commit pending changes to disk"? Or would that somehow disrupt the UX?

See above.


Holger


-- 
Sent from /e/ OS on Fairphone3


Reply to: