[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#607417: win32-loader: please offer a "Boot from network with gPXE" option



block 607417 by 474034
thanks

Hi Alkis, and thanks for your bugreport, 

> We've modified it a bit so that it adds a "Boot from network" entry in
> the Windows boot loader, instead of loading a Linux kernel.
> To accomplish this we statically linked gpxe.lkrn [1] to
> win32-loader.exe, and we modified main.nsi to load this instead of
> vmlinuz. No initrd was necessary.

Nice.

> Currently the resulting "ltsp-loader.exe" [2] is used in some thousand
> Greek school PCs to netboot thin and fat clients. But many others have
> asked for this functionality in the #ltsp irc channel and in the
> ltsp-discuss mailing list, so we think it'd be much better if the
> upstream win32-loader Makefile supported a "Boot from network with gPXE"
> target.
> 
> Unfortunately gPXE is not yet in Debian due to (afaik) some unresolved
> licensing issues. However if the win32-loader Makefile supported a gPXE
> target, maybe one of the following would be possible:
>  * The gPXE devs to compile win32-loader with the gPXE target, and to
>    host the resulting win32-loader-gpxe.exe on their site themselves.
>  * Or a sysadmin or user could do that for his own use.
>  * Or win32-loader.exe could dynamically download gpxe.lkrn from the
>    gPXE website.

As gPXE is not in Debian, I don't think it would be correct to upload a 
win32-loader including said functionality in Debian right now (in particular 
not in these times of freeze). Hence I marked that bug "blocked" by the gPXE 
ITP.

But more generally, I don't see a reason to keep your patch out: merging is 
always good.

> If you want we can send you the .diff for main.nsi that we currently
> have, but we aren't very skilled with NSIS scripting so if you decide to
> add that functionality upstream you'd probably want to properly
> reimplement this yourselves. :)

Please do so; attach the patch to this bugreport so that we can take a look 
at it.

> In any case thanks again,
> Alkis Georgopoulos

Thanks also go to you for making such a nice use of win32-loader. :->

Cheers, OdyX

-- 
Didier Raboud, proud Debian Maintainer (DM).
CH-1020 Renens
didier@raboud.com

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.


Reply to: