[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#267913: installation-reports: set timeout for syslinux



Kenshi Muto wrote:
> I found d-i won't progress when I use tftpboot with USB keyboard (non
> BIOS PS/2 emulation).
> 
> Of course d-i is loaded, but because syslinux timeout is defined as
> infinite and control of USB keyboard is already passed to OS instead
> of BIOS, so I couldn't input Enter key and start progress.
> (By changing timeout value of tftp configuration, I can succeed.)
> 
> IMHO it is better to all syslinux has appropriate timeout value (1
> minute?).
> 
> I found "set the syslinux timeout to 0 on floppys, to match the CD" by
> JoeyH in debian-installer's changelog. Does timeout cause a trouble?

The timeout was changed to zero after some users got annoyed or confused
that the installation started without them doing anything, and without
them having time to read the boot screen.

I don't understand how the "control of USB keyboard is already passed to
OS" when only isolinux is running, and not any OS. isolinux uses the
BIOS to read the keyboard. Also, nobody else is reporting problems with
USB keyboards, or at least many report they work, so are you sure you have
it set up appropriatly in your BIOS?

If this were a general problem with syslinux and USB keyboards, then
using a timeout does not seem to me to be an acceptable solution. Many
users need to type kernel parameters into syslinux to get a working
install.

-- 
see shy jo

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: