[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#93810: AEST vs EST for Australian time



Hi all,
I am the submitter of that long-standing Debian bug,
http://bugs.debian.org/93810, wherein I contend that 'AEST' should be
used as the timezone name for Australia's eastern states, not 'EST'. It
was suggested in this report that 'Australians do not use AEST'. Aside
from the fact this was based on a stunningly bad assertion, it's untrue.

Let me assure you, as an Australian who's lived in Australia my whole
life, that when we are writing something that will be seen by a global
audience, we use AEST rather than EST. This is entirely empirical, and I
can't really back it up, other than assure you that there's not exactly
a financial incentive for me to lie or something - I just want to see
this mess cleared up.

And then there's the stunningly bad basis for this outlandish claim -
Googling for 'aest site:.au' vs. 'est site:.au'. Aside from the fact
that a lot of us have non-.au sites (I personally have
people.debian.org, fooishbar.org, penguinppc.org, and many more - this
is not at all uncommon, and grows when you consider LiveJournal,
blogger, etc), this claim is *just* *plain* *wrong*.

http://www.googlefight.com/cgi-bin/compare.pl?q1=aest+site%3A.au&q2=est+site%3A.au&B1=Make+a+fight%21&compare=1&langue=us

This URL shows that 'aest site:.au' comes up with 332,000 results,
compared to 323,000 for 'est site:.au'. Even the worst basis for any
argument is factually incorrect, not just staggeringly irrelevant.

As an Australian with actual first-hand (as opposed to Google-derived)
knowledge of the situation, I urge you to switch to AEST.

Thanks,
Daniel

(Please keep me CC'ed on all this, I am not subscribed, and I will not
 see mail to 93810@bugs.debian.org, only
 93810-submitter@bugs.debian.org).

-- 
Daniel Stone                                                <daniels@debian.org>
Debian X Strike Force:                    http://people.debian.org/~branden/xsf/

Attachment: pgpE0vd27yXpn.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Reply to: