Re: [Nbd] [PATCH 2/3] nbd: fsync and kill block device on shutdown

[Andrew Morton <akpm@...133...>]

On Tue, 12 Feb 2013 17:06:10 +0100
Paolo Bonzini <pbonzini@...696...> wrote:

> There are two problems with shutdown in the NBD driver.  The first is
> that receiving the NBD_DISCONNECT ioctl does not sync the filesystem;
> this is useful because BLKFLSBUF is restricted to processes that have
> CAP_SYS_ADMIN, and the NBD client may not possess it (fsync of the
> block device does not sync the filesystem, either).

hm, this says that the lack of a sync is "useful".  I think you mean
that the patch-which-adds-the-sync is the thing which is useful, yes?

> The second is that once we clear the socket we have no guarantee that
> later reads will come from the same backing storage.  Thus the page cache
> must be cleaned, lest reads that hit on the page cache will return stale
> data from the previously-accessible disk.

That sounds like a problem.

> Example:
> 
>     # qemu-nbd -r -c/dev/nbd0 /dev/sr0
>     # file -s /dev/nbd0
>     /dev/stdin: # UDF filesystem data (version 1.5) etc.
>     # qemu-nbd -d /dev/nbd0
>     # qemu-nbd -r -c/dev/nbd0 /dev/sda
>     # file -s /dev/nbd0
>     /dev/stdin: # UDF filesystem data (version 1.5) etc.
> 
> While /dev/sda has:
> 
>     # file -s /dev/sda
>     /dev/sda: x86 boot sector; etc.

OK, we've described the problems but there's no description here of how
the patch addresses those problems.


How does this look?


: There are two problems with shutdown in the NBD driver.
: 
: 1: Receiving the NBD_DISCONNECT ioctl does not sync the filesystem. 
: 
:    This patch adds the sync operation into __nbd_ioctl()'s
:    NBD_DISCONNECT handler.  This is useful because BLKFLSBUF is restricted
:    to processes that have CAP_SYS_ADMIN, and the NBD client may not
:    possess it (fsync of the block device does not sync the filesystem,
:    either).
: 
: 2: Once we clear the socket we have no guarantee that later reads will
:    come from the same backing storage.
: 
:    The patch adds calls to kill_bdev() in __nbd_ioctl()'s socket
:    clearing code so the page cache is cleaned, lest reads that hit on the
:    page cache will return stale data from the previously-accessible disk.
: 
: Example:
: 
:     # qemu-nbd -r -c/dev/nbd0 /dev/sr0
:     # file -s /dev/nbd0
:     /dev/stdin: # UDF filesystem data (version 1.5) etc.
:     # qemu-nbd -d /dev/nbd0
:     # qemu-nbd -r -c/dev/nbd0 /dev/sda
:     # file -s /dev/nbd0
:     /dev/stdin: # UDF filesystem data (version 1.5) etc.
: 
: While /dev/sda has:
: 
:     # file -s /dev/sda
:     /dev/sda: x86 boot sector; etc.