Bug#810600: ITP: minimap -- tool to find approximate mapping positions between long sequences
* Sascha Steinbiss [Sun, Jan 10 2016, 02:25:28PM]:
> Hi Eduard,
> > * Sascha Steinbiss [Sun, Jan 10 2016, 11:40:58AM]:
> >> Package: wnpp
> >> Severity: wishlist
> >> Owner: Sascha Steinbiss <firstname.lastname@example.org>
> >> * Package name : minimap
> >> Version : 0.2
> >> Upstream Author : Heng Li <email@example.com>
> >> * URL : https://github.com/lh3/minimap
> >> * License : MIT
> >> Programming Lang: C
> >> Description : tool to find approximate mapping positions between long sequences
> > Sounds misleading to me. By looking at the package name and short
> > description, I expected some tool for GIS, not biology.
> I see your point. However, I’d like to state for the record though that ‘mapping’ is a very common term in contemporary biological sequence analysis and minimap is not the first such tool to bear the word ‘map’ in the name or description.
> What would you think about changing the short description to explicitly mention biological sequences. How about ’tool for efficient approximate mapping of long biosequences such as DNA reads’.
Maybe "tool for efficient approximate mapping of long biosequences" or
"tool for efficient approximate mapping of long biosequences like DNA reads"
But I am not a native speaker and don't have strong preferences here.
> One could also think of renaming the package to ‘minimap-bio’ or the like as a lat resort, but I would rather avoid that.
I would stick to upstream name as long as possible. Once a while ago I
made the mistake of deviating from upstream just for cosmetic reasons
and it always sucked.