Re: Picking a new member - process
Don Armstrong writes ("Re: Picking a new member - process"):
> On Thu, 07 Nov 2013, Andreas Barth wrote:
> > If we vote only on those who are proposed here by a tech ctte member,
> > this would decrease the number of people voted below FD. Plus,
> > everyone should be number one on at least one vote (or I hope at least
> > people only propose someone who would be number one on their vote)
>
> Or at least, only those who you would rank above FD.
I agree that it would be perverse to propose someone and then rank
them below FD. (We can't make a rule against it since the procedure
is constitutionally determined, but we can point out to our colleagues
that we think it's a bad idea.)
> With this clarification, what Ian proposed originally is acceptable to
> me.
Good.
> [My reading comprehension of the constitution and of Ian's original mail
> was pretty dismal today; only after reading your reply did I realize
> that Ian meant that CTTE members would be proposing nominees, not the
> public in general.]
Err, yes.
Ian.
Reply to: