[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

pcmciautils utility for CardBus (Re: Bug#698105: Please remove pcmciautils from laptop task)



Hi Colin,

Colin Watson wrote:
On Mon, Jan 14, 2013 at 06:33:53AM +0100, Michael Biebl wrote:
>  PCMCIA is so uncommon nowadays that installing pcmciautils on every laptop
>  by default is imho no longer warranted. I would thus like to see it removed
>  from task-laptop, similar to apmd.
>  PCMCIA has been a technology which was relevant in the 1990s and has
>  been superseded by e.g. ExpressCard for over 10 years.
>
>  I've CCed Colin, the pcmciautils maintainer, for his input.

pcmciautils is a slightly misleading name, as it does some CardBus
handling as well.  However, it's true that udev improvements mean that
it's no longer actually needed to get anything other than 16-bit PCMCIA
cards up and running; so I think this proposed tasksel change is OK.

If pcmciautils can actually be useful in any way for CardBus in wheezy, the misleading name is a secondary problem considering that while the short description, the extended description and the manual pages mention PCMCIA, none say anything about CardBus. I do not see any clue from the package that it could help CardBus.


Reply to: