[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

[Debconf-team] make bed selection a lottery



Hi,

instead of turning DebConf13 into a travel agency which will have to manage 
requests, demands and complaints (even more than we already have to deal with 
every year) and giving richer people an opportunity to buy their beds of 
choice and forcing poorer people into left-over beds, I suggest a completly 
different protocol:

Do a lottery. announce it as a lottery and do such.

Maybe we could give everybody 5 tickets (for free if sponsored) and allow them 
to buy more tickets for say, 50 CHF per ticket. (And a ticket could just mean 
drawing a random number between 1 and 1000.)

For registration, everybody ranks their choices of bed/room, incl. the option 
"I'd rather not come then sleep in this".

And then we draw numbers per tickets, add those per person and the highest 
number wins (the first choice of bed/room), the 2nd highest wins the 2nd 
choice, etc, down until the last choice.

This is a bit unpredicatble, but it's also fair(er) and rather predictable 
that its unpredicatable too.

And of course, everybody can still swap on indidivual bases as usual.


I'm sorry to not have come up with a more solid proposal about this yet, but I 
think its a good start and definitly better then making an already quite-
money-centric debconf even more money-centric. We are divided by money all the 
time, and even more, while doing DebConf in Switzerland. The pricing-room-
proposal will widen this gap even more, while this lottery proposal aims at 
lessing this gap a little bit at least.


cheers,
	Holger




p.s.: and in this model, also coorporate could mean 10 tickets "for free" and 
professional 15 tickets "for free". and then they can buy more tickets to 
improve their chances. this way we can nicely make clear that people should 
not expect debconf-team to be a travelagency

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.


Reply to: