Re: Constitutional amendment: Condorcet/Clone Proof SSD vote tallying

[Markus Schulze <markus.schulze@alumni.tu-berlin.de>]

Hallo,

here is an extreme violation of the participation criterion.

Situation 1:

   A:B=206:94
   A:C=160:140
   A:D=161:139
   A:E=162:138
   A:F=96:204
   B:C=202:98
   B:D=163:137
   B:E=164:136
   B:F=205:95
   C:D=203:97
   C:E=93:207
   C:F=165:135
   D:E=228:72
   D:F=166:134
   E:F=201:99

   Candidate A is the unique beat path winner.

Situation 2:

   10 AEFCBD voters are added.

   A:B=216:94
   A:C=170:140
   A:D=171:139
   A:E=172:138
   A:F=106:204
   B:C=202:108
   B:D=173:137
   B:E=164:146
   B:F=205:105
   C:D=213:97
   C:E=93:217
   C:F=165:145
   D:E=228:82
   D:F=166:144
   E:F=211:99

   Candidate D is the unique beat path winner.

This example demonstrates that the extreme violation of
the participation criterion has nothing to do with quorum
requirements.

Markus Schulze